77 guests from the United States made a booking in the last minute

FREE cancellation on most rooms!
Instant confirmation when you reserve

3 properties in Shelter Island

Show map

Hotels that guests love in Shelter Island

  • I went to Shelter Island on a "girlfriend weekend". We didn't know what to expect, but were pleasantly surprised. The inn was spectacular and Beth was very gracious. The location of Seven is ideal....close to beach, restaurants and ferry. I cannot wait to return !

    Debbie, Group from the United States
  • Lobby Ambience was lovely- like a step back in time and the restaurant was very nice with good service. A beautiful scenic view from the restaurant and front of the Inn. The breakfast was wonderful and the staff gracious.

    Mature couple from the United States
  • location,dinner at restaurant,view,bar

    Mature couple from the United States
  • Staff was helpful and friendly. Location was wonderful. Plenty of help from check-in to bar to dinner

    William, Mature couple from the United States
  • Staff was very attentive and the room was clean and had a nice view. Dinner was very good as we sat outside and had a wayer view. A nice getaway for the evening. We did not stay long enough to take advantage of the bikes and boats

    Frank, Mature couple from the United States

In and Around Shelter Island, New York State

Places of Interest


Show me hotels in nearby cities:

Other Accommodations

Different ways to stay in Shelter Island:

More Hotel Themes

Popular Hotels in Shelter Island

See where others are staying...

Sunset Beach
The Pridwin Hotel Good 7.4 All staff gave professional, expert and sincerely helpful and courteous service. Helped with our itinerary. And gave the impression that no question would be too small or too great ! Very caring and efficient !

See how Booking.com rates

  • 4.3/5 From 9,829 reviews
  • 88.4% of users recommended Booking.com

Shelter Island, NY   3 properties

Save money in Shelter Island
We'll send you our best discounts
Get deals

Just Booked

    My Lists
    Choose a check-in date
    Choose a check-out date

    Enter your email address and we'll resend your confirmation

    + _
    Close map