Shelter Island was highly rated for relaxation by 6 guests from the United States!

FREE cancellation on most rooms!
Instant confirmation when you reserve

In and Around Shelter Island, New York State

Places of Interest

Cities

Show me hotels in nearby cities:

Other Accommodations

Different ways to stay in Shelter Island:

More Hotel Themes

Different ways to stay in Shelter Island:

See how Booking.com rates

  • 4.5/5 From 9357 reviews
  • 90.9% of users recommended Booking.com
notgogplace
My Lists   Lists
Choose a check-in date
Choose a check-out date