Barceló Edinburgh Carlton Hotel

It was central and accessable to all areas of the city, although 5 minute walk from railway station I would be inclined to disagree with !!

the breakfast was not the best -- and very expensive .

splendid location but dirty, stuffy hotel. Great potential wasted due to bad maintenance and housekeeping:

Overheated, dusty rooms, terrible air, bad cleaning, broken bed, dysfunctional lighting in rooms, no WIFI

The location.

Receptionists had a hard time smiling or being friendly.

The bed was really comfy

There was just enough towels for myself and my guest, but no extra ones, or bath robes :(

The hotel was in a great location close to the Royal Mile. It was also conveniently located for all of Edinburgh's city centre attractions and handy for visiting our son, who is presently studying in Edinburgh. The hotel is a lovely old building with plenty of charm and character, yet the interior decor was quite contemporary and provided a nice contrast. We were also given a room upgrade, which is always a nice touch.

Only minor issue was that our room, on the second floor, overlooked the busy street below. As such it was quite noisy all through the night and we didn't sleep particularly well.

ideal location, very clean and friendly staff

no car park

Excellent room sizes and comfort. Quite liberal about guests (e.g. fridge for drinks rather than the usual extortionate mini-bar)

The leisure/spa facilities were quite run down and spa out of service)

location, surroundings and comfort of bed!!

stayed 2 nights, breakfast first morning was very enjoyable, unfortunately next morning was not, i understand that it was very busy, we waited 10 minutes befor anyone came to show as to our table, which was full of dishes, we were told to get our breakfast and the table would be ready on our return, there was only cutlery when we came back, we asked for a pot of tea, which came after 5 minutes, we had no cups or saucers, after 15 minutes i had to go and find some, by which time the tea was cold. there was to scrambled eggs at the buffet table, we stood for 10 minutes, when none arrived, i asked for some, to be told it would be another 10 minutes! i was very disappointed as the trip was a birthday gift for my sister!

The location

Lack of decent toiletries and for a twin room only one set of toiletries.I would recommend the hotel largely for location.

I was very disappointed that although the room was classified non-smoking the bed had an extremely strong smell of cigarette smoke. Had it not been so late when we checked in I would have complained and asked to be moved. As I am undergoing chemotherapy at the moment this was extremely unpleasant. Obviously the room has been a smoking room in the past and the smell is imbedded in the fixtures and furnishings.

The Central location (right on the Royal Mile) was excellent for both the University Open Day and for sightseeing, and I easily found a car park charging £16 for 24 hours parking. Not bad considering the relatively small size of the Central Area.

I booked this room for a visitor, not for myself. He checked into the hotel, but when I came to meet him, the hotel staff denied that they had a person of that name staying, and would not tell me whether anyone else with the same family name was there. This was very annoying. Fortunately, he turned up shortly afterwards. The hotel should have a better practice regarding information concerning a guest whose room has been reserved by a person who can identify themself.