The Macdonald Roxburghe Hotel  

I can not say that I will choose this hotel again. It did not give me anything positive. It is very expensive for the services it provides . I will rate it the most two star.

Breakfast was very poor in quantity , style and type of food. Our stay was 6 nights and every day for breakfast was scrambled eggs,eggs sunny side up,beacon, sausages. Every day a little after 08:30 ,(breakfast started at 07:00 ), the pans ,bowls, plates and tables were almost completely empty of food. The staff which was in charge of breakfast did not refill the food.I Had to remark and call out to the staff continuously each morning for them to bring out food.This was very expensive breakfast to pay for in comparison for the quality and most of the time there was a shortage. The coffee cups were dirty inside. The manager sent me a letter informing me that I should pay for the whole six nights on the second day of our stay.I Rate this hotel two stars the most.The rooms are not cleaned right there is dust all over the furniture.

The bed was extremely comfortable . The staff were friendly and the downstairs of the hotel is nicely decorated and modern

We had to wait 1 hr before we could get into our room at 3pm. The room was dated and not what was advertised on the website. No water supplied or a fridge in the room.

The place is very well located with direct access to city center. The personnel are of great kindness and education

The parking in hotel and surroundings is horrendously expensive

Nice friendly staff, good location.

Cleanliness in bathroom not as good as I would have expected of a 4*

Great building in an excellent location. Comfortable big room and bathroom. Good service in lounge bar.

Breakfast was one of the worst I have ever had in any hotel. The service was slow and fussy - there were far too many people doing the serving of tables and they got in each other's way. We were asked seven times if everything was OK and for the first three of those questions we had not got our ordered food. When the food arrived it was poor, it varied in temperature (the sausage was so hot it burned my mouth, the mushroom was near cold and the poached egg was too far undercooked). We had a far better breakfast the next two mornings at a place next door, for half the price!

Excellent location, just round the corner from the main shopping area. Close to Edinburgh Castle. Very comfortable rooms. Our room was at the front of the building but we did not hear any traffic noise as one other reviewer had said. Staff were very helpful and curteous. We got the bus from the airport which dropped us off just accross the road. We would definitely recommend this hotel and if we ever return to Edinburgh, we will certainly stay at the Roxburghe Hotel.

Just one small gripe, the safe in our room did not work but staff at reception stored our valuables in the hotel safe.

We liked everything it was brilliant.

Recently rennovated, the hotel was fresh & clean. Location just off George St is perfect for a break in Edinburgh and suited our requirements perfectly.

Toileteries ran out very quickly when sharing a twin room (we should have requested more!). The hotel also delivered a Sunday paper then charged for it. There was no mention of this at check-in which was a little disappointing.

I requested a large room and got just that with a fab view over Charlotte Sqare. The service was impeccable and very friendly. Breakfast was excellent.

Good sized rooms with very large comfortable bed

The hotel must be refurbished. The gym and spa facilities are not very clean and very old. The interiors of the room are a

Every member of staff was polite and said hello. This was our first stay in a hotel like this and we enjoyed it very much. Was a bit more expensive than hotels we usally use but was a late honeymoon so was a treat and was very enjoyable. Thankyou

Lamp wasn't working on dressing table. My wife found it to do makeup and hair in the morning