The only thing that I would have to say about the place is that you should really check on what room you get, as they are all unique--none bad that I saw, just different. The fisherman's house is on the pool level, which worked well for us. Unfortunately, the people next door (the gardener's house) were not the most considerate about the varying assigned balcony spaces (gardener's balcony is actually set apart from the room and the people staying there took to hanging towels and such on our assigned chairs). The sailor's room seemed pretty comparable to ours, but the gardener's was definitely smaller.
My fiancée and I stayed here when I asked her to marry me--perfect setting. The location is fantastic, not right in the main Oia area, but within a very easy walk. Sunsets in September are over the tip of the island, not the water, but the view was still amazing. The staff is very nice and helpful and breakfasts are great. Stayed in the fisherman's house, which was great. Included drinks like wine, beer, soda, and water.