Food is a little pricey, as others have mentioned, and not a lot of choices, but of good quality. Slow service at the restaurant, but with no schedule to keep it was not a huge problem.
My wife and I really enjoyed this place. We stayed at three places during a week in Puerto Rico and liked this one best. The location is great, if a little remote. We were able to visit both Gilligan Island and the Bioluminescent Bay (with some effort). Very low-key atmosphere, and plenty of room. Since it was shoulder season not many people were on the property. A number of rooms are currently being renovated, which will be a nice upgrade. Great friendly, helpful staff, especially the water sports staff and the captain of the boat that goes to Gilligan Island and gives evening cruises (free, with rum punch, too!)