|
City Club Hotel
|
||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
When would you like to stay at the City Club Hotel?
Top
Based on
178
reviews
|
|
Show scores of: |
Individual guest reviews
Reviews are ordered by language and date with a maximum of 25 reviews per page.
|
Sergio
Mature couple
Santiago,
Chile
November 19, 2009
|
The hotel is located in a very good spot for shopping, walking around and good eating. The atmosphere of the hotel is special and it has a touch of elegance. Perhaps you can find that the lightning is poor, but it belongs to the decoration, you can enhance it anytime. The hotel satff was very polite and prepared to assist you in any minute. The only thing I would improve would be the poor relationship to the outside. If I opened the window I found a brick wall close to it, like in a bad horror film. I couldn not sleep a night because a standing nose like a hammer tapping continously for hours. |
9.5 |
|
Dolores
Young couple
Clonmel,
Ireland
November 17, 2009
|
Close to all city attractions. Very helpful concierge desk, found tickets for a basketball match the next day within minutes. Free internet with printing was great. The room was quite stuffy, despite the air conditioning. Also it might be worth showing a plan of a petite room as it is quite difficult to visualise just how small it is from the photos. Some tiles were lifting off the floor in the bathroom and rooms just a little bit worn. |
7 |
|
Stephane
Young couple
laval,
Canada
November 13, 2009
|
Location, and general atmosphere. Size of the room (too small), and the fact that we had a roach in our room and the manager didn't offer to change our room, in fact it seemed that it was not is problem, that it was normal.... I will never stay there again |
4.5 |
|
Anonymous
Solo traveller
United States of America
November 11, 2009
|
Hotel is located at the center with an easy access to every place, very close to subway, hotel staff is kind and helpful, delicious cookies left to room every day, room was clean and comfortable |
10 |
|
Anonymous
Solo traveller
United Kingdom
November 10, 2009
|
A good shower and great complimentary toiletries, the goodnight cookies Dark corridors, no decent reception/lobby area, the two rooms I tried - both had noisy ac units and are the first us rooms I have stayed in that did not have coffee making facilities - the first had a pipe on the outside wall which made a loud noise all through the night - the second which I asked to be moved to so I could get some sleep was about half the size but charged at the same rate - the wardrobe was only tall enough for a jacket and you had to move the desk to open the wardrobe door. The cost - I have stayed in far better places for considerably less; this hotel is the worst value I have ever experienced - even after they conceded a 50usd reduction because of the noise in the first room. |
5 |
|
Stanislava
Young couple
Prague,
Czech Republic
November 9, 2009
|
Design and location very dark room with poor lightening, value didn't correspond to the price payed. |
6 |
|
Anonymous
Mature couple
United States of America
November 4, 2009
|
The convenience of the location. Clean and well maintiained. Helpful staff and the daily fresh cookies! The room we had only had one window that was dirty and looked out into back area. So there was no real light. Other than that it was a lovely room and very nice small city hotel. |
10 |
|
Anonymous
Group
United States of America
November 3, 2009
|
attentive staff, beautiful decor--but wish the rooms had some daylight. |
10 |
|
Derek
Mature couple
San Francisco,
United States of America
October 30, 2009
|
The location was excellent, the staff responsive and friendly, and the design of the room (though small) and bathroom (gorgeous and large), top-notch. I enjoyed having the NY Times at the door every morning, and the delivery of choclate chip cookies every evening. The most unfortunate aspect of our particular room was the lack of good lighting, whether in the room or bathroom. Natural light was basically non-existent. Without the ability to crack open the windows, we relied on the air conditioning system - even then it was often stuffy and warm during the night. |
8 |
|
Thomas
Mature couple
Buffalo, New York,
United States of America
October 26, 2009
|
Hotel is walking distance from numerous activities in and around Times Square yet located down a side street which reduces traffic and pedestrian noise. Great location to walk to almost anywhere |
9.5 |
|
Maria
Family with older children
San Sebastian,
Spain
October 25, 2009
|
Very friendly staff! |
7.5 |
|
Jamal
Solo traveller
Dubai,
United Arab Emirates
October 25, 2009
|
location room very very small !!!! |
7 |
|
Anne
Family with older children
Hellerup,
Denmark
October 23, 2009
|
Nice location, great design, room size fine, friendly staff |
7.5 |
|
Craig
Young couple
Lakeville,
United States of America
October 23, 2009
|
The room was clean and was not too small. The hotel was quiet at night. |
8 |
|
Graham
Family with older children
Southampton,
United Kingdom
October 22, 2009
|
Staff very friendly & helpful, location superb just off 5th Avenue & also close enough to walk a few blocks across to Times Square. Rooms very clean, beds made dailey & plenty of towels too. Would definately stay their on our next visit to New York!! No tea or coffee making facilities in room, but a great coffee shop across the road & there happy for you to bring it into the hotel. |
9 |
|
Anonymous
Solo traveller
United States of America
October 21, 2009
|
It was the most exceptional staff (front desk, doormen, restaurant) of any hotel in which I've stayed. It is small, so I expect they have fewer names and faces to remember, but it was quite impressive. The bathroom was exceptionally well laid out - particularly since I stayed in a petite room. The rate was about 15% lower than the other hotels on the block, and I wouldn't hesitate to go back. The bed was not the most comfortable I've had in a hotel. It was not uncomfortable. I would try to brighten the hallways a bit. The decor is stylish and ambiance tranquil, but it is a bit too dark when you get on and off the elevator. |
9 |
|
Rosalyn
Solo traveller
Fillongley Coventry,
United Kingdom
October 20, 2009
|
By NY standards it was like staying in someones house!! Small, intimate,and very friendly, I was travelling alone on this trip and it was like returning to peace and calm after the madness of the city. Location was fantastic. A wonderful welcome on arrival. Quirky, unusual and would recommend it to anyone for a really relaxing stay in NY. Thank you. |
10 |
|
Jody
Family with older children
Calgary,
Canada
October 15, 2009
|
Location, size, amenities (internet access, restaurant, room service). Staff were very pleasant and helpful. The total experience was positive! We would definately come back to City Club in New York. Restaurant was a bit overpriced for amount of food served. |
10 |
|
John
Young couple
NEW MILFORD,
United States of America
October 14, 2009
|
Very comfortable bed. Room very small. |
9 |
|
Laurita
Family with young children
Oak Brook,
United States of America
October 14, 2009
|
The room was very comfortable. the hallways were dark |
9.5 |
|
Anonymous
Mature couple
United States of America
October 7, 2009
|
Location was excellent. Near enough to times square yet far enough to avid the noise. Rooms a little small. |
9 |
|
Dan
Mature couple
Targu Jiu,
Romania
September 21, 2009
|
The excellent location, the friendly attitude of the staff, the clean room and bathroom Rooms were too small, but for this excellent location is probably more than common! |
8.5 |
|
Ioana
Family with older children
Thornhill,
Canada
September 16, 2009
|
The location is great, the room was large enough for 4 people, loved the day bed. The idea with the TV behind the mirror wasn't good at all as, while watching, you can see your reflection or the lights instead of what's on. It was also too expensive for what it offered other than the location. |
6 |
|
Anonymous
Young couple
Netherlands
September 12, 2009
|
Nice hotel staff, nice looking room (not the usual bad/cheap taste hotel room look). During the stay we were several times positively suprised by different aspects of the services from this hotel, and it definately added to the enjoyment of our stay in Manhattan. The location in midtown is simply right on the spot for a lot of this things we did. (top of the rocks, moma, theater, times square and shopping etc.) We definately recommend this hotel to others. |
10 |
|
Tani
Family with older children
Crailsheim,
Germany
September 10, 2009
|
Its confortable, location is great and staff is very friendly |
10 |
The guest reviews express the personal opinions of Booking.com customers who filled out a questionnaire after their stay at the hotel. These opinions do not necessarily represent the views of Booking.com.
Customers viewing this hotel are often interested in these hotels as well:
Crowne Plaza Times Square  With a prime location right in Times Square, this luxurious midtown Manhattan hotel offers exciting on-site dining and comfortable guestrooms just steps from a variety of city attractions. |
Stay. With a fantastic location steps from Times Square, this Manhattan hotel features on-site dining, a seasonal rooftop bar with stunning city views and modern in-room amenities, including iPod docking... |
Best Western President Hotel at Times Square The sites and sounds of Broadway are the backdrop for this cozy hotel, located in the heart of Times Square, and featuring state-of-the-art amenities and recently renovated accommodations. |
Paramount Hotel Times Square New York  Offering convenient access to the Broadway Theater District and Restaurant Row, this hotel in Manhattan's exciting Times Square offers contemporary facilities and delicious on-site dining options. |
){kind=link}
){kind=link}