I'll make this quick: I usually scour several travel sites and read tons of reviews before I book a budget or economy hotel, because you never know what you're going to get for $60, so if you're reading this, I'm sure you do the same and I'll save you some time. This hotel is at the top of the pack for a BUDGET/ECONOMY hotel, and the review (stars) is based on a BUDGET/ECONOMY hotel, of which I have stayed in many, and not The Plaza, which will probably never happen.
The staff was super kind and friendly, the room was clean and comfortable, and the breakfast was fulfilling for starting our day. The walk to Old Town was quick.
Of note, one staff member told me they would be updating the rooms sometime this year (new bedspreads/décor/etc), and I was surprised; I really didn't think it was necessary. The furnishings were more than clean, fresh, and adequate.
Enjoy your stay!