Saved to 54 lists

Resort highlights

Free WiFi Free parking

Activities:

Hot Tub Indoor Pool (seasonal)
Show map Montauk Blue Hotel

Customers who viewed Montauk Blue Hotel also viewed:

Montauk Manor

hotel Featuring on-site spa services and a restaurant, Montauk Manor is in Montauk, New York. The property showcases an indoor and an outdoor swimming pool. Free Wi-Fi access is available.

Most recent booking for this hotel was yesterday at 19:33

Score from 356 reviews Excellent 8.7/10

Kenny's Tipperary Inn

hotel A 4 minute walk from the Block Island Ferry, this Montauk hotel offers an on-site restaurant and an outdoor pool. Free Wi-Fi is included in all guest rooms.

Most recent booking for this hotel was yesterday at 18:56

Score from 130 reviews Good 7.7/10

Oceanside Beach Resort

hotel This Montauk beachfront property is a 10 minute drive to the Montauk Point Lighthouse and is less than one mile from Montauk town center.

Most recent booking for this hotel was yesterday at 22:00

Score from 205 reviews Very good 8/10

Wavecrest Resort

hotel Featuring sweeping views of the ocean from every unit, this Montauk resort has an indoor and outdoor pool. An on-site, private beach is just steps away.

Most recent booking for this hotel was yesterday at 19:54

Score from 72 reviews Good 7.9/10

Newest reviews for Montauk Blue Hotel

  • Anonymous
      United States of America
    August 27, 2014

    i loved being right on the water and being able to walk right onto the beach

    the noise from partiers all night long and no one at the desk to take my call after midnight

    9.6

  • Chris
      United States of America
    August 26, 2014

    Right on the beach 2 blocks from town

    Expensive

    8.3

  • Ivan
      United Kingdom
    August 26, 2014

    The position is stunning

    The guests were very young and noisy

    8.3

  • Karen
      United States of America
    August 26, 2014

    Location great. Deck

    Way Over priced on weekends A small small frig and microwave does not make A "kitchenette" Floor of bathtub was weird. Like an air bubble was under neath.

    7.1

  • Joanne
      United States of America
    August 24, 2014

    The convenience of beach and town. Pool was very nice also. Late checkout would have been nice but understood busy time of year .

    The reception could have been a little but nicer when my friend asked for extended checkout time. Absolutely not, was not a nice way to answer

    8.8

  • Agnes
      United States of America
    August 23, 2014

    Pretty nice hotel, that was partially refurbished. Modern and clean. Right on the beach.

    I had issues with their doors, flimsy locks and you had to slam their doors to close. If a guest came in at 3 in the morning you heard their door slam for sure! As I said this place was partially refurbished. They kept the old bathtub in mine and my brother's family's room. Also one small wastebasket in the bathroom was not sufficient. Need another one in the room itself. Stairs going up to second floor were rickety.

    6.7

  • Anonymous
      United States of America
    August 22, 2014

    The deck overlooking the beach was great, never crowded. The beds were comfortable. Loved the decor!

    There was a stove top but no cookware.

    9.6

  • Henry
      United States of America
    August 20, 2014

    Room decor Ease of beach access Bed comfort Bathrooms Proximity to village hot spots

    no outdoor pool

    8.8

  • Elizabeth
      United States of America
    August 19, 2014

    Location on ocean. Proximity to restaurants and shops. Able to walk to many loved our stay

    Nothing

    9.6

  • Victoria
      United States of America
    August 19, 2014

    Right on the beach and close to the main strip.

    8.8

  • Anonymous
      United States of America
    August 16, 2014

    location

    door to room sticks,only one trash can in bathroom and none in room, room not ready at check in time, tv was disconnected & had to call twice before a response from front desk

    5

  • Thomas
      United States of America
    August 14, 2014

    You are literally on the beach, great view of the ocean, easy to walk right into the heart of town, newly painted so appears decent, good family spot.

    Outdoor stairs at the hotel are wobbly and scary when carrying luggage. Hot tub water was green and gross, Pool is in shade but indoors so good for kids to get out of the sun but not a beach alternative. Ice machine always empty. Balcony furniture of 2 very cheap resin chairs, balcony screen wouldn't slide, stains on the rug...this is not a luxury hotel but the room price says otherwise. No attention to detail.

    5.8

  • Steven
      United States of America
    August 13, 2014

    Coming for years and the only thing that is still enjoyable is the deck and being on the beach. As long as you get one with the terrace.

    Although renovated, really cheaped out. No flat screen tv. Curtains absolutely were filthy and stunk. One tiny trash pail. Phone didn't work, sink backed up, refrigerator didn't work, screen door had to be fixed. Made an improvement in linens. We made a decision not to go back.

    5

  • Anonymous
      United States of America
    August 12, 2014

    Convenient locatio

    Where pool was located

    7.1

  • Anonymous
      United States of America
    August 10, 2014

    Right on the beach with ocean views from our room.

    No outdoor shower or foot shower to clean away all that sand.

    7.5

  • Anonymous
      United States of America
    August 9, 2014

    Great location right on the beach. Check in was fast and they called you when your room was ready. Close to restaurants and stores

    refrigerator was too small with no freezer compartment, bad parking availability as it was open to anyone. They should make their parking lot for hotel guests only.

    7.9

  • Anonymous
      United States of America
    August 9, 2014

    Close to town, close to the beach, nice pool.

    Parking was not always available it seems that the spaces are used by non-guests.

    7.5

  • Frank
      United States of America
    August 9, 2014

    Newly renovated room. Hotel acknowledged my special request and was able to forfill it for an upper room. Excellent view.

    9.2

  • Anonymous
      United States of America
    August 9, 2014

    Indoor Pool Balcony overlooking the ocean Location

    What happened to the kitchen? We were very disappointed that this was not included in the renovations. We enjoyed having the kitchen when we stayed previous times.

    10

  • Anonymous
      United States of America
    August 7, 2014

    Everything

    no blow dryer in the room

    10

  • Donna
      United States of America
    August 6, 2014

    Much cleaner and updated than comparable montauk motels.

    Rates for same room vary a little too much. I paid $249, spoke to other guests who paid $450-$650 for same room, same night.

    9.2

  • Anonymous
      Netherlands
    August 6, 2014

    Location, perfect at the beach. Nice room, good bed.

    The evening staff was very impolite. We made a booking through Booking.com and the guy at the desk wanted us to pay four times the rate we payed with bookings. Eventually he (and I) called with bookings and with a lot of complaints he agreed to give us the room key. The next day the manager apologized for his behavior, that we appreciated.

    6.3

  • Stratos
      United States of America
    August 6, 2014

    The Montauk Blue Hotel was Absolutely Fabulous The Location was Perfect centrally located in downtown Montauk In walking distance of all the little stores and delicious restaurants The beach was so clean and at night many family and friends were lighting fires and sitting around I cannot wait to visit again and would Highly reccomend The Montauk Blue Hotel

    Nothing not to Like

    9.2

  • Dominick
      United States of America
    August 5, 2014

    Great location on the beach and walking distance to restaurants, bars and shops in downtown Montauk. Clean.

    No amenities. Should have chairs on beach and beach towels. Rooms small. Only paid $300 on booking.com rackrate of $1600 would be ridiculous. Need more parking. Front door lock broken. Bathroom door did not close completely.

    6.7

  • Anonymous
      United States of America
    August 5, 2014

    location on the beach

    noisy, tiny motel rooms, overpriced even for the summer season

    4.2

Close map