Choose your preferred language. We speak English (US) and 41 other languages.
35 Shore Road, Shelter Island, NY 11965, United States of America – Show map
Excellent location – rated 9.2/10! (score from 3 reviews)
Rated by guests after their stay at Sunset Beach.
No booking fees • Save money! Best price guarantee — enter dates to see these prices!
3 properties in Shelter Island
Including hotels, apartments, villas and more.
We verify all reviews. Find out more.
They speak your language!
Sunset Beach's staff speaks: English
Booking is safe
When you book with us your details are protected by a secure connection.
WiFi is available in all areas and is free of charge.
Free public parking is available on site (reservation is not needed).
From 4:00 PM
Until 11:00 AM
Cancellation and prepayment policies vary according to room type. Please enter the dates of your stay and check what conditions apply to your preferred room.
Children and Extra Beds
All children are welcome.
One child under 17 years stays free of charge when using existing beds.
Any additional older children or adults are charged USD 100 per person per night when using existing beds.
Extra beds are not available.
One child under 2 years stays free of charge in a crib.
The maximum number of cribs in a room is 1.
Additional fees are not calculated automatically in the total cost and will have to be paid for separately during your stay.
Pets are allowed on request. Charges may apply.
Cards accepted at this property
Hover over the cards for more info.
Other Places You Might Like
Guests are required to show a photo ID and credit card upon check-in. Please note that all Special Requests are subject to availability and additional charges may apply.
We need at least 5 reviews before we can calculate a review score. If you book and review your stay, you can help Sunset Beach meet this goal.
Located 2 miles from Wainscott Beach, this motel features a seasonal outdoor pool. It has guest rooms with free Wi-Fi and free guest parking.
Score from 85 reviews Good
On Crescent Beach, this Shelter Island hotel has an outdoor pool overlooking the bay, a private beach, free Wi-Fi and rooms with cable TV. The North Ferry is 2 miles from the property.
Score from 57 reviews Good
Just 5 minutes' walk to the beach, this bed and breakfast is located in Shelter Island Heights. A free breakfast is served each morning at the on-site restaurant.
Score from 32 reviews Exceptional
With beautiful views of the sunsets over Long Island Sound, this Greenport resort features spacious grounds and a private beach. Free Wi-Fi is available in all areas.
Score from 29 reviews Very good
May 19, 2015
Overpriced! It should have included continental breakfast. The restaurant service was a bit disappointing. And there was no one available at the front desk after 10pm.
The room was lovely but the bathroom is very small.
September 16, 2014
Restaurant was extremely expensive especially for breakfast. I also thought the $9 beach ball in the room was ridiculous. For the price of the room that should be a gift!
The rooms were immaculate beautiful and comfortable. The view was beautiful and staff extremely pleasant.
September 15, 2014
When i made reservation, they charged my AMX card for half [ 8/18 ], now i just checked my account on line, and i'm being charged the full amount $362, not happy, i called AMX, the charges are going through
Get started now by entering your email address. We'll instantly send you a link to our Deal Finder!