Skip to main content

Filter by:


Star Rating

5 stars 4 stars 3 stars 2 stars 1 star

Review Score

Awesome: 9+ Very Good: 8+ Good: 7+ Pleasant: 6+
Shelter Island – 5 hotels and places to stay
Our Top Picks Lowest Price First Star rating and price Top Reviewed

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.

Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island

Shelter Island

Just 1476 feet to the beach, this bed and breakfast is located in Shelter Island Heights. A free breakfast is served each morning. Fantastic time. Beth and Dominica were delightful!!!

Show more Show less
9.8
Exceptional
63 reviews

Luxurious 'Shelter Island Hideaway' with Pool!

Shelter Island

Luxurious 'Shelter Island Hideaway' with Pool!, a property with free bikes, is located in Shelter Island, 6.2 mi from Mashomack Preserve.

Show more Show less

Plum Guide - Villa Menantic

Shelter Island

Located in Shelter Island, 0.8 mi from Wades Beach and 3.1 mi from Mashomack Preserve, Plum Guide - Villa Menantic offers free WiFi and air conditioning.

Show more Show less
Avg. price/night:
$978.33

Plum Guide - Sunrise Dew

Shelter Island

Located in Shelter Island, 1969 feet from Wades Beach and 1.9 mi from Mashomack Preserve, Plum Guide - Sunrise Dew provides accommodations with free WiFi, air conditioning, free bikes and a garden.

Show more Show less
Avg. price/night:
$716.14

Romantic Shelter Island Cottage with 2 Pools and Pond

Shelter Island

Located in Shelter Island in the New York State region, Romantic Shelter Island Cottage with 2 Pools & Pond features a balcony.

Show more Show less

The Inn at Harbor Knoll

Greenport (Near Shelter Island)

Located in Greenport, The Inn at Harbor Knoll offers accommodations with free WiFi and flat-screen TV, as well as a shared lounge and a garden. A beautiful inn in a fabulous location. Spotlessly clean and very nice room. First class breakfast and complimentary wine and snacks provided by the owner. Extremely friendly and helpful owner and staff.

Show more Show less
9.6
Exceptional
31 reviews

The Harborfront Inn

Hotel in Greenport

Offering a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a fitness center, The Harborfront Inn is centrally located near the shops and restaurants in Greenport. Free WiFi access is available. Beautiful bathroom , wonderful comfy bed in a huge room with a wonderful view. Lovely breakfast included. All in all a lovely experience

Show more Show less
9
Awesome
308 reviews
Avg. price/night:
$148

The Menhaden Hotel

Hotel in Greenport

The Menhaden Hotel features air-conditioned accommodations in Greenport. Located right in the heart of Greenport, this is an oasis of urban sophistication in an otherwise quaint North Fork town. Surprisingly upscale and very attentive team. Clean and efficient.

Show more Show less
9.2
Awesome
31 reviews
Avg. price/night:
$378.35

Greenporter Hotel

Hotel in Greenport

Featuring a 1950’s retro décor, the rooms at Greenporter Hotel rooms have modern amenities like a flat-screen cable TV and a refrigerator. I came for one night in the fall and I was never able to get a room in the summer - they are always booked. The facility is not new but very clean and the service is wonderful. Everybody here is so kind and polite. I was traveling solo and I felt very good in here. Excellent complimentary breakfast.Thank you very much!

Show more Show less
8.3
Very Good
141 reviews
Avg. price/night:
$99

American Beech Hotel

Hotel in Greenport

Located in Greenport, American Beech Hotel has a restaurant, bar, garden, and free WiFi throughout the property. The hotel features family rooms. Very secluded. Perfect for a relaxing weekend

Show more Show less
8.7
Excellent
191 reviews
Avg. price/night:
$199
Subscribe to see Secret Deals

Prices drop the second you sign up!

What Guests Said About Shelter Island:

Explore guest reviews of hotels in Shelter Island

See all