Skip to main content

Filter by:


Star Rating

Review Score

Put-in-Bay – 10 hotels and places to stay
See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.
Edgewater Hotel and Suites, hotel in Put-in-Bay

Located in Put-in-Bay, 16 mi from Sandusky, Edgewater Hotel and Suites features an outdoor pool and hot tub. Guests can enjoy the on-site restaurant.

They have a great staff and location. The rooms are always clean and comfortable. This was our second year there at this time.
6.3
Scored 6.3
Pleasant
Rated pleasant
188 reviews
Price from$149.64per night
Anchor Inn Boutique Hotel, hotel in Put-in-Bay

The adult-only Anchor Inn is a full service, casually elegant, luxury hotel located just 3 blocks from downtown Put-In-Bay.

Location is best on the island.
9.5
Scored 9.5
Exceptional
Rated exceptional
171 reviews
Price from$225per night
Islander Inn, hotel in Put-in-Bay

Located in Put-in-Bay and with Perry s Cave reachable within a 14-minute walk, Islander Inn provides a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, non-smoking rooms, free WiFi and a bar.

Clean room
7.4
Scored 7.4
Good
Rated good
270 reviews
Price from$154.10per night
Grand Islander Hotel, hotel in Put-in-Bay

Located in Put-in-Bay, a 13-minute walk from Perry s Cave, Grand Islander Hotel has accommodations with a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, free private parking and a bar.

The location and staff were great!
6.5
Scored 6.5
Pleasant
Rated pleasant
104 reviews
Price from$139per night
Bay Lodging Resort, hotel in Put-in-Bay

Located on the island of Put-In-Bay, Ohio, this resort features both indoor and outdoor pools and a hot tub. Free WiFi access is available in this Lake Erie property.

Nothing
7.2
Scored 7.2
Good
Rated good
389 reviews
Price from$152.22per night
Ahoy Inn Guesthouse, hotel in Put-in-Bay

Ahoy Inn Guest house is set in Put-in-Bay, 15 mi from Sandusky and 30 mi from Leamington. The property offers European styled rooms, free WiFi and private parking.

Excellent location. Very friendly staff. Wonderful place to stay.
9.1
Scored 9.1
Wonderful
Rated wonderful
242 reviews
Price from$139per night
Bird's Nest Resort, hotel in Put-in-Bay

Bird's Nest Resort offers accommodations in Put-in-Bay, 1.1 miles from Perry s Cave. Both free Wifi and parking on-site are available at the bed and breakfast free of charge.

Staff was wonderful, very kind and welcoming. The location was perfect for us! Our kids loved the pool area. We would definitely come back again
8.5
Scored 8.5
Very Good
Rated very good
130 reviews
Price from$189.10per night
Chapman House, hotel in Put-in-Bay

Providing lake views, Chapman House in Put-in-Bay features accommodations and a garden. Perry s Cave is within 1.5 miles of the condo hotel.

This was our 4th stay at Chapman House. we love the Halloween weekend on PIB this was our 8th Halloween weekend. as long as they have a room we will stay there!!!
9.0
Scored 9.0
Wonderful
Rated wonderful
74 reviews
Price from$200per night
Bodee's Bungalow Adults Only Couples Only Boutique Hotel, hotel in Put-in-Bay

Set in Put-in-Bay, Bodee's Bungalow Adults Only Couples Only Boutique Hotel provides most accommodations with private entrances. With barbecue facilities, the property also has a garden.

Everything
9.6
Scored 9.6
Exceptional
Rated exceptional
34 reviews
Price from$129per night
All Star Ohio House, hotel in Put-in-Bay

A 15-minute walk from Perry s Cave, the vacation home offers a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a bar. The vacation home has a picnic area and a hot tub.

This is to all people who want to thinking rent this house . I was in put in bay area around 11:30pm with 5 month baby . I don't find any hotel in that area, And i book this so called house. I call the property to get directions but the dude who received my call told me he is a driver he don’t know anything,need to call resort to get a pin and conformation. I told him that i have both information with me in my email. He hang up his phone and never received phone again.
5.3
Scored 5.3
Average
Rated fair
6 reviews
Price from$800per night
See all 72 hotels in Put-in-Bay
Subscribe to receive premium deals

Prices drop the second you sign up!

What Guests Said About Put-in-Bay:

  • 6.0
    Scored 6.0

    make sure you request the room you want to be in. golf carts...

    make sure you request the room you want to be in. golf carts is a must to get around. Mojhto Bay bar is awsome. Frosty is a great place to eat. The Goat has great steaks. Most places are just seafood.
    Sandra
  • 8.0
    Scored 8.0

    Good food at some great restaurants.

    Good food at some great restaurants. Nice time with family for a casual couple day trip. Easy to get around island, although golf cart can be pricey. Bring your walking shoes. If you're looking for more laid back, recommend going on weekdays as things get a little crazy on the weekends.
    Darleen
    United States of America
  • 4.0
    Scored 4.0

    Sometimes the less said the better, not cheap, Property is...

    Sometimes the less said the better, not cheap, Property is lacking needed update! Dirty, in the heart of loud music noise till 2:00 AM. Drinking and loud conversation outside the rooms sometimes rowdy gathering of drunken guests!!
    Stephen
    United States of America
  • 4.0
    Scored 4.0

    Overall not super impressed, payed almost $900 for my stay...

    Overall not super impressed, payed almost $900 for my stay and our shower would soak our bathroom floor because of the shower curtain. We didn't have a microwave in the room. We weren't allowed to park our golf cart on their property. Also they barely have any parking. I walked 40 mins to pick up my golf cart rental so I wouldn't have to worry about finding parking for my car again, it took like 20 minutes the first time to find parking. Also they only have breakfast on weekdays, and we didn't really have any form of protein at our breakfast. It was mostly cereal, bread for toast, begals muffins, and cheap danishes. Staff was overall friendly, but they preferred talking amongst themselves overall. I probably will not stay here again.
    A
    Anonymous
  • 6.0
    Scored 6.0

    When we booked our trip the site never said that most...

    When we booked our trip the site never said that most businesses were closed for the season. We had never been to Put In Bay, and we were mot aware of this, and the website leads you to believe everything is open. There was nothing to do during our stay after the first day. It was very cold, we took a golf cart to visit what businesses were open. Leaving the island to try to find something to do, was not possible. The ferry on our 2nd day (Tuesday) stopped running at 11:30a.m. leaving us virtually nothing to do, we still had 2 days left in our stay, and we would have been stuck there. We asked the hotel if we could get a refund for the 2 days we had left, the girl working the desk said there was nothing she could do we would have to go thru booking.com. We contacted Booking.com and they said they couldn't do anything, that we would have to go thru the hotel. Very unprofessional to give us the run around, they had no desire to help us. We decided to leave anyway because we did not want to be stuck on the island. Very poor Customer Service experience. Also, very misleading website doesn't say businesses were closed for the season, and still doesn't. Hotel room was not clean, and looked nothing like the pictures online. Definitely do not recommend Put In Bay Resort and Conference center, it was dirty and staff very unfriendly. We will never stay here again.
    Michelle
    United States of America
  • 10
    Scored 10

    It was a perfect family/friend destination.

    It was a perfect family/friend destination. Not overly commercialized. Things to do for all ages. We visited Moss Bach, Hooligans and The Reel Bar - all of them had wonderful food and great staff. We did drive over but the golf carts were more fun and easier to get around in Love the ferry ride.
    S
    Suzanne
    United States of America