Looking for properties near Mashomack Preserve?

Then you've come to the right place! Enter your dates and choose from 78 properties.

More than 1 million people last month said they'd recommend Booking.com to their family and friends.

FREE cancellation on most rooms! Instant confirmation when you reserve

Featured Hotels Near Mashomack Preserve

Guests' Choice
  • $399

    Average price per night

    Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island

    Seven - a boutique B&B on Shelter Island 4 stars

    Shelter Island (3.9 miles from Mashomack Preserve)

    9.7 Exceptional 143 reviews
    Description Review
  • $449

    Average price per night

    Baron's Cove

    Baron's Cove 4-star hotel

    Sag Harbor (3.8 miles from Mashomack Preserve)

    8.9 Excellent 144 reviews

    2 people are looking right now

    Description Review
  • $236

    Average price per night

    House on Chase Creek

    House on Chase Creek 4 stars

    Shelter Island Heights (3.8 miles from Mashomack Preserve)

    9.3 Wonderful 27 reviews
    Description Review
  • Shelter Island House 4-star hotel

    Shelter Island Heights (3.8 miles from Mashomack Preserve)

    9.3 Wonderful 13 reviews
    Description Review
  • $275

    Average price per night

    The Chequit

    The Chequit 4 stars

    Shelter Island Heights (3.9 miles from Mashomack Preserve)

    8.8 Excellent 46 reviews
    Description Review
  • $259

    Average price per night

    The Harborfront Inn

    The Harborfront Inn 3-star hotel

    Greenport (4.9 miles from Mashomack Preserve)

    9.1 Wonderful 279 reviews
    Description Review