Recent reviews
“Everything is great”
“I enjoy the concept of the hotel; to give a home feel inside a hotel stay.”
“Close to the airport, big room and good facilities. Only stayed overnight between flights, but would happily book again as beds were very comfy.”
“I didn’t see a breakfast station”
“The service”
“Room was clean and basic. Bed very comfortable. Good choice of breakfast each day and staff very attentive.
Clean towels available at reception if extras required.
Convenient to family members during our stay.”
“Everything. But customer service definitely trumps all. They were absolutely amazing. We will be returning and this time bringing the kids”
“Room was lovely, good view, good breakfast on the whole”
“location was convenient to my work location”
“Clean quiet”
The 30 Best Hotels in Long Island
based on 52,356 Hotel Reviews on Booking.com
Guests' Choice
Fathoms Hotel & Marina
Ranked
1
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
1 for hotels in Port Washington .
Last review posted: 50 days ago
“A do not miss place to stay, THIS HOTEL, and Port Washington.”
“The Owners made us feel at home and we enjoyed our conversations.”
“From the extremely comfortable rooms, the warm bagels and croissants that are left outside your bedroom door each mornin”
See more reviews of Fathoms Hotel & Marina
The Menhaden Hotel
Ranked
2
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
12 for hotels in Greenport .
Last review posted: 8 days ago
“One of the thing I love most when I stay at a hotel is...”
“Great stay , clean the best Staff”
“Warm, cozy, and well worth it!”
See more reviews of The Menhaden Hotel
Hartman's Briney Breezes Beach Resort
Ranked
3
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
28 for hotels in Montauk .
Last review posted: yesterday
Hotel Moraine
Ranked
4
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
3 of
12 for hotels in Greenport .
Last review posted: 2 days ago
“It's a very nice hotel.”
“We will be back!”
“Luxury stay with exceptional amenities. Friendly staff. Great location”
See more reviews of Hotel Moraine
The Roundtree, Amagansett
Ranked
5
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
5 for hotels in Amagansett .
Last review posted: 10 days ago
“Small boutique hotel but so lovely”
“Lovely and accommodating staff and really nice property.”
“Amazing place to stay, authentic paradise.”
See more reviews of The Roundtree, Amagansett
The Preston House and Hotel
Ranked
6
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
10 for hotels in Riverhead .
Last review posted: 2 days ago
“The location was perfect for staying near the Hamptons and...”
“Parking, bathroom and room”
“Nice hotel but for $400 during the off-season a night not worth the money”
See more reviews of The Preston House and Hotel
Aqualina Inn Montauk
Ranked
7
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
2 of
28 for hotels in Montauk .
Last review posted: 188 days ago
“Great location, great price. We would definitely come back.”
“Lovely little place.”
“Great Location! Very Clean! Friendly Staff!”
See more reviews of Aqualina Inn Montauk
Residence Inn Long Island Garden City
Ranked
8
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
5 for hotels in Garden City .
Last review posted: 10 days ago
“Fantastic hotel!!!”
“Very well kept”
“Second time staying here while working in Long Island.”
See more reviews of Residence Inn Long Island Garden City
The Ocean Resort Inn
Ranked
9
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
3 of
28 for hotels in Montauk .
Last review posted: 205 days ago
“The best stay”
“Great place to stay”
“Just the best.”
See more reviews of The Ocean Resort Inn
The Inn At Fox Hollow Hotel
Ranked
10
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
3 for hotels in Woodbury .
Last review posted: 5 days ago
“Service was excellent”
“clean and bigger rooms, swimming pool not available, they...”
“Diuble billed and that sucks”
See more reviews of The Inn At Fox Hollow Hotel
The Shoals Suites & Slips
Ranked
11
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
4 for hotels in Southold .
Last review posted: yesterday
“Breakfast was very good and what was expected.”
“Wonderful !”
“Amazing Stay!”
See more reviews of The Shoals Suites & Slips
Hilton Garden Inn Roslyn
Ranked
12
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
3 for hotels in Roslyn .
Last review posted: 10 days ago
“The stay was amazing.”
“The fitness room was clean and well equipped.”
“Overall, enjoyed our stay at this hotel.”
See more reviews of Hilton Garden Inn Roslyn
The Sunset Montauk
Ranked
13
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
4 of
28 for hotels in Montauk .
Last review posted: yesterday
“From the beginning to the end, excellent!”
“if the weather is good, you would enjoy the stay much better than us!”
“Very happy with our experience there!”
See more reviews of The Sunset Montauk
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Ranked
14
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
4 of
12 for hotels in Greenport .
Last review posted: 5 days ago
“Amazing”
“Room was very clean and comfortable.”
“Wonderful getaway. We will be back.”
See more reviews of Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Colonial Shores Resort
Ranked
15
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
2 of
8 for hotels in Hampton Bays .
Last review posted: 200 days ago
“Clean and easy”
“Excellent”
“Very relaxing”
See more reviews of Colonial Shores Resort
The Bentley Hotel Southampton
Ranked
16
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
2 of
10 for hotels in Southampton .
Last review posted: yesterday
“Nicest motel ever.”
“We had a pleasant short getaway!”
“overall, very comfortable, wouldn’t hesitate to book again!”
See more reviews of The Bentley Hotel Southampton
The Hermitage at Napeague
Ranked
17
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
2 of
5 for hotels in Amagansett .
Last review posted: 32 days ago
“How can a resort just change your location without your consent”
“Beautiful but cold”
“Everything was great.”
See more reviews of The Hermitage at Napeague
Montauk Manor
Ranked
18
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
5 of
28 for hotels in Montauk .
Last review posted: yesterday
“Relaxing and enjoyable.”
“Stunning views
”
“The bed in rm 109 has to be replaced.”
See more reviews of Montauk Manor
Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven
Ranked
19
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
2 for hotels in Yaphank .
Last review posted: 2 days ago
Bridgehampton Inn
Ranked
20
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
2 for hotels in Bridgehampton .
Last review posted: 10 days ago
“Nice place for a night or 2”
“Adequate”
“The Matre De was outstanding, Couldn't ask for better...”
See more reviews of Bridgehampton Inn
Sea Crest
Ranked
21
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
1 for hotels in Amagansett .
Last review posted: yesterday
“Mattress a little worn”
“Paradise so close to home”
“Our stay was really good. We had a great time on the beach and evening walks in the neighborhoods. The location is reall”
See more reviews of Sea Crest
Ocean View Terrace
Ranked
22
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
3 of
8 for hotels in Hampton Bays .
Last review posted: 2 days ago
“Great Stay”
“We had a lovely stay and would definitely come back again”
“The owner and staff are very nice and willing to accommodate to make your stay pleasurable”
See more reviews of Ocean View Terrace
Marram
Ranked
23
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
7 of
28 for hotels in Montauk .
Last review posted: 12 days ago
“Great Hotel”
“Magical place in Montauk right next to the beach.”
“Beautiful location and lovely stay.”
See more reviews of Marram
The Quogue Club
Ranked
24
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
1 for hotels in Quogue .
Last review posted: 12 days ago
“Beautiful hotel”
“Enjoyable stay!”
“Very good”
See more reviews of The Quogue Club
112 Motel
Ranked
25
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
3 for hotels in Medford .
Last review posted: 7 days ago
“Great stay”
“Gem of a place”
“It was good tho”
See more reviews of 112 Motel
Sun and Sound Montauk
Ranked
26
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
8 of
28 for hotels in Montauk .
Last review posted: 188 days ago
“Wonderful”
“The manager is a a sweetheart she is absolutely amazing!”
“Overall a great experience the staff were very accommodating and thoughtful and let us check out later after telling the”
See more reviews of Sun and Sound Montauk
American Beech Hotel
Ranked
27
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
5 of
12 for hotels in Greenport .
Last review posted: 17 days ago
“Fun night stay”
“Staff was amazing, and communicated throughout our stay. The restaurant on site had fairly priced food, and was deliciou”
“Perfect stay and we’ll be back again”
See more reviews of American Beech Hotel
Holiday Inn - Long Island - ISLIP Arpt East, an IHG Hotel
Ranked
28
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
2 for hotels in Holtsville .
Last review posted: 2 days ago
“Delightful place to stay!”
“Good but far away from NYC”
“The front desk clerk was very accommodating”
See more reviews of Holiday Inn - Long Island - ISLIP Arpt East, an IHG Hotel
Montauk Blue Hotel
Ranked
29
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
9 of
28 for hotels in Montauk .
Last review posted: yesterday
“Refreshing”
“It was relaxing and pleasant”
“We had a family with children above us and they ran around...”
See more reviews of Montauk Blue Hotel
Aqua by American Beech - Adults Only
Ranked
30
out of
160 in the region, as well as being
1 of
1 for hotels in Aquebogue .
Last review posted: 3 days ago
“Private”
“Great location wonderful staff.”
“It was perfect”
See more reviews of Aqua by American Beech - Adults Only
Previous page
1
2
3
4
5
6
Next page
Start of dialog content
How does it work?
It starts with a booking
It starts with a booking
The only way to leave a review is to first make a booking. That's how we know our reviews come from real guests who have stayed at the property.
Followed by a trip
Followed by a trip
When guests stay at the property they check out how quiet the room is, how friendly the staff are and more.
And finally, a review
And finally, a review
After their trip, guests tell us about their stay. We check for naughty words and verify the authenticity of all guest reviews before adding them to our site.
If you booked through us and want to leave a review, please sign in first.
End of dialog content