Skip to main content

Stay in Fire Island's best hotels!

Filter by:


Star Rating

5 stars 4 stars 3 stars 2 stars 1 star

Review Score

Wonderful: 9+ Very Good: 8+ Good: 7+ Pleasant: 6+
Our Top Picks Lowest Price First Star rating and price Top Reviewed

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.

The Blue Parrot Guest House

Hotel in Ocean Beach

Providing free WiFi, The Blue Parrot Guest House offers rooms in Ocean Beach, 20 miles from Nikon Theater and 20 miles from Jones Beach.

Show more Show less
Price from
$209.50
per night

Palms Hotel Fire Island

Hotel in Ocean Beach

Palms Hotel Fire Island features a garden, terrace, a restaurant and bar in Ocean Beach. The staff were amazing but the room was moldy. The hallways smelled terribly of mold and there was not a mattress pad on the bed and no washcloths were given. The bathroom fan was louder than a freight train. The service was so nice and helpful. Added bonus were bikes, chairs ,towels and wagons.

Show more Show less
6.9
Review score
17 reviews

Grove Hotel

Hotel in Cherry Grove

Grove Hotel is located in Cherry Grove and features a bar. Featuring a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, the 3-star hotel has air-conditioned rooms with free WiFi, each with a private bathroom. The place has been redone , and it is a great option.

Show more Show less
7.5
Good
35 reviews

Clegg's Hotel

Hotel in Ocean Beach

Located in Ocean Beach and with Ocean Beach reachable within a 8-minute walk, Clegg's Hotel has concierge services, allergy-free rooms, free bikes, free WiFi and a terrace. Great location right when you get off the ferry. Next door to a convenient store. Bike rental, beach chairs and umbrella included with your stay!!

Show more Show less
7.4
Good
30 reviews

Sea La Vie

Ocean Beach

Sea La Vie offers accommodations in Ocean Beach, 20 miles from Jones Beach and 14 miles from Bergen Point County Golf Course. The air-conditioned accommodation is 20 miles from Nikon Theater. Such a wonderful place to stay! Has the whole family and it was so spacious!!

Show more Show less
8.8
Excellent
5 reviews

Cherry Grove Enchantment

Cherry Grove

This beachfront property offers access to a patio and free Wifi. The air-conditioned vacation home consists of 6 bedrooms, a living room, a fully equipped kitchen with a dishwasher and a coffee...

Show more Show less

Poolside Chic by the Sea - Ocean Bay Park, NY

Ocean Beach

Offering a garden, Poolside Chic by the Sea - Ocean Bay Park, NY offers accommodations in Ocean Beach. This property offers access to a terrace, free private parking, and free Wifi.

Show more Show less
Price from
$5,700
per night

Fire Island White House - Ocean Bay Park, NY

Ocean Beach

Fire Island White House - Ocean Bay Park, NY is located in Ocean Beach, just a 4-minute walk from Ocean Beach and 20 miles from Nikon Theater.

Show more Show less
Price from
$4,000
per night

Glamorous Pines Home

Fire Island Pines

This vacation home offers air-conditioned accommodations with free Wifi. Outdoor dining is also possible at Glamorous Pines Home.

Show more Show less

The Blue Parrot Cottage

Ocean Beach

The Blue Parrot Cottage offers accommodations in Ocean Beach, 20 miles from Nikon Theater and 20 miles from Jones Beach. Guests staying at this vacation home have access to a patio.

Show more Show less
Price from
$345
per night

Hotels with extra health and safety measures

Find hotels in Fire Island with added hygiene measures plus high cleanliness ratings

Safety features
Physical distancing
Cleanliness & disinfection
Food & drink safety