Stays Flights Flight + Hotel Car Rentals Attractions Airport Taxis

Stay in Long Island's best hotels!

Filter by:


Star Rating

5 stars 4 stars 3 stars 2 stars 1 star

Review Score

Awesome: 9+ Very Good: 8+ Good: 7+ Pleasant: 6+
Our Top Picks Lowest Price First Star rating and price Top Reviewed

The Harborfront Inn

Hotel in Greenport

Offering a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a fitness center, The Harborfront Inn is centrally located near the shops and restaurants in Greenport. Free WiFi access is available. Beautiful hotel, very clean, friendly and welcoming receptionist, GREAT bed, linens, and pillows. The bathroom was wonderful even though it took a while to figure out the shower. 😊 (there were 6 nozzles). The location is ideal.

Show more Show less
9
Awesome
289 reviews
Avg. price/night:
$199

Garden City Hotel

Hotel in Garden City

The Garden City Hotel features 272 guest rooms and suites. The property is located in Long Island’s Garden City, in New York. A seasonal outdoor dining area is featured on site. This was one of the best days I have ever had in the New York area. The staff is incredible. The hotel is elegant and very comfortable. I certainly would stay there again. The hotel is very close to local eateries giving you a nice local experience. The area is very safe.

Show more Show less
9.2
Awesome
206 reviews
Avg. price/night:
$167.20

Residence Inn Long Island Garden City

Hotel in Garden City

Featuring barbecue facilities, Residence Inn Long Island Garden City is located in Garden City in the New York State region, 3.5 miles from Adelphi University. Adherence to the CDC guidelines

Show more Show less
9
Awesome
34 reviews
Avg. price/night:
$174

The Roundtree, Amagansett

Hotel in Amagansett

Located in the Village of Amagansett, Town of East Hampton, The Roundtree, Amagansett features free bikes, garden, BBQ facilities, and free WiFi. Free Private Parking is available at the property. The property is so new and clean and well decorated. The location is perfect - walking to everything you need. A little farther walk to beach but they also provide bikes. So much space for enjoying the grounds and having kids play. The rooms are spacious and all of the decorations/ linens/amenities are so high end. I also love that they did NOT nickel and dime you - all snacks in room were free, free breakfast and so many things to borrow like chairs, wagons and umbrellas for beach included. As much as I LOVED the property the staff was EXCEPTIONAL!! They anticipated my every need. Kevin was amazing - he set up golf reservations at Montauk Downs which is kind of impossible to get. He helped set up babysitters as well. The entire staff was so accommodating especially to our very chatty 5 year old. I never once had them tell me no to a request. I also loved the turn-down service. Overall I would give this place a 100 if the scale went that high. It was truly magical and we can’t wait to go back! Thank you Roundtree for making our vacation such a dream.

Show more Show less
9.7
Exceptional
16 reviews
Avg. price/night:
$395

The Menhaden Hotel

Hotel in Greenport

Located in Greenport, The Menhaden Hotel has a restaurant, free bikes, bar, and free WiFi throughout the property. Featuring family rooms, this property also provides guests with a terrace. EXCELLENT HOTEL great staff. Extremely accommodating and VERY CLEAN.

Show more Show less
9.2
Awesome
29 reviews
Avg. price/night:
$427.90

The Preston House and Hotel

Hotel in Riverhead

Located in Riverhead, 3.1 mi from Tanger Outlets Riverhead, The Preston House and Hotel offers amenities including a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a fitness center. Marvelous architecture -- honoring the work and creation of ancestors and providing new, modern hotel: rooms with space and excellent, excellent showers, bath, "kitchenette" areas and service. Bed, totally comfortable, includes perfect, light comforter for the colder months.

Show more Show less
9.3
Awesome
56 reviews
Avg. price/night:
$249

The Quogue Club

Hotel in Quogue

Set in Quogue, 24 mi from East Hampton, The Quogue Club features air-conditioned rooms with free WiFi. Guests can enjoy the on-site bar. Free private parking is available on site. Great bed, quiet, lovely food, warm friendly service. Nice touches in every way.

Show more Show less
9.1
Awesome
39 reviews
Avg. price/night:
$275

Bay Breeze Inn

Hotel in South Jamesport

Located on the beachfront in South Jamesport and featuring a shared lounge, Bay Breeze Inn has free WiFi throughout the property. Location was perfect. Clean and very comfortable. Staff was very helpful and friendly.

Show more Show less
9.2
Awesome
18 reviews
Avg. price/night:
$200

TownePlace Suites Republic Airport Long Island Farmingdale

Hotel in Farmingdale

Located within the Grounds of the Republic Airport, TownePlace Suites offers self-contained accommodation 20 miles from New York City proper. It features a free airport shuttle and a 24-hour gym. Cleanliness. Good Behaviour from staff. Breakfast was good, As a feedback i will say, you Can include some fruit everyday. It's so good that Hotels and ATM nearby within walking distance. And thanks to the Uber facility. Front desk staff were so good.

Show more Show less
9
Awesome
59 reviews
Avg. price/night:
$173.88

Montauk Manor

Hotel in Montauk

Offering on-site spa services, Montauk Manor is located in Montauk, New York. The property features an indoor and an outdoor swimming pool. Free Wi-Fi access is available. The people who work there! Patrick and Chez so friendly! The view is stunning!!!!! Rooms have EVERYTHING you need! The manor is full of atmosphere and has a cosy fireplace! Deers can be seen on the property also! Beautiful!!

Show more Show less
8.8
Excellent
2,004 reviews
Avg. price/night:
$132

Hotels with extra health and safety measures

Find hotels in Long Island with added hygiene measures plus high cleanliness ratings

Safety features
Physical distancing
Cleanliness & disinfection
Food & drink safety

Most-booked hotels in Long Island in the past month

See all

Long Island's best hotels with breakfast

See all

Budget hotels in Long Island

See all

Hotels in Long Island you can book without a credit card

See all

FAQs about hotels in Long Island

Explore guest reviews of hotels in Long Island

See all