Get the advice you need. Check the latest COVID-19 restrictions before you travel. Learn more

Stay in Long Island's best hotels!

Filter by:


Star Rating

5 stars 4 stars 3 stars 2 stars 1 star

Review Score

Awesome: 9+ Very Good: 8+ Good: 7+ Pleasant: 6+
Our Top Picks Lowest Price First Star rating and price Top Reviewed

See the latest prices and deals by choosing your dates.

Fathoms Hotel & Marina I

Hotel in Port Washington

Located in Port Washington, Fathoms Hotel & Marina I has a bar, shared lounge, garden, and free WiFi. Guests can have a drink at the snack bar. At the hotel, all rooms are equipped with a closet. location, amenities, personal touch and warm welcome from Steve and Cindie throughout my stay .. they couldn’t do enough!

Show more Show less
9.6
Exceptional
42 reviews
Price from
$344.19
per night

The Roundtree, Amagansett

Hotel in Amagansett

Located in the Village of Amagansett, Town of East Hampton, The Roundtree, Amagansett features free bikes, garden, BBQ facilities, and free WiFi. Free Private Parking is available at the property. The property is so new and clean and well decorated. The location is perfect - walking to everything you need. A little farther walk to beach but they also provide bikes. So much space for enjoying the grounds and having kids play. The rooms are spacious and all of the decorations/ linens/amenities are so high end. I also love that they did NOT nickel and dime you - all snacks in room were free, free breakfast and so many things to borrow like chairs, wagons and umbrellas for beach included. As much as I LOVED the property the staff was EXCEPTIONAL!! They anticipated my every need. Kevin was amazing - he set up golf reservations at Montauk Downs which is kind of impossible to get. He helped set up babysitters as well. The entire staff was so accommodating especially to our very chatty 5 year old. I never once had them tell me no to a request. I also loved the turn-down service. Overall I would give this place a 100 if the scale went that high. It was truly magical and we can’t wait to go back! Thank you Roundtree for making our vacation such a dream.

Show more Show less
9.6
Exceptional
26 reviews
Price from
$595
per night

Bridgehampton Inn

Hotel in Bridgehampton

Bridgehampton Inn features a restaurant, bar, a shared lounge and garden in Bridgehampton. Featuring room service, this property also provides guests with a terrace. breakfast was cooked to order an excellent.

Show more Show less
9
Awesome
57 reviews
Price from
$527
per night

The Menhaden Hotel

Hotel in Greenport

The Menhaden Hotel in Greenport has a bar and a terrace. Among the facilities of this property are a restaurant, a 24-hour front desk and room service, along with free WiFi throughout the property. The hotel is beautifully designed, exceptionally clean, ample snacks, beverages available free of charge, but the absolute standout is the staff/service. Within moments of reserving our room, i received a text from the property welcoming us and offering their services. Their suggestions, assistance were outstanding!!!!! Rooftop deck is wonderful!!!!!!

Show more Show less
9.4
Awesome
76 reviews
Price from
$394.40
per night

The Preston House and Hotel

Hotel in Riverhead

Located in Riverhead, 3.1 mi from Tanger Outlets Riverhead, The Preston House and Hotel offers amenities including a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a fitness center. The staff are amazing great team

Show more Show less
9.2
Awesome
84 reviews
Price from
$325
per night

The Quogue Club

Hotel in Quogue

Set in Quogue, 24 mi from East Hampton, The Quogue Club features air-conditioned rooms with free WiFi. Guests can enjoy the on-site bar. Free private parking is available on site. Breakfast was delicious, with lots of good options.

Show more Show less
9
Awesome
34 reviews
Price from
$450
per night

EHP Resort

Hotel in East Hampton

Located in East Hampton in the New York State Region, 4.3 mi from Atlantic Avenue Beach, EHP Resort features a seasonal outdoor pool and children's playground. Manager and staff aim to please. Beautiful location and highly recommend

Show more Show less
9
Awesome
16 reviews
Price from
$595
per night

Montauk Manor

Hotel in Montauk

Offering on-site spa services, Montauk Manor is located in Montauk, New York. The property features an indoor and an outdoor swimming pool. Free Wi-Fi access is available. WE UPGRADED & ALSO RECEIVED FREE UPGRADE. OFF SEASON PRICES.

Show more Show less
8.7
Excellent
2,499 reviews
Price from
$156
per night

Residence Inn Long Island Garden City

Hotel in Garden City

Located in Garden City and with Adelphi University reachable within 3.5 miles, Residence Inn Long Island Garden City provides express check-in and check-out, non-smoking rooms, a shared lounge, free... such a beautiful hotel. I would stay here anytime I travel

Show more Show less
8.9
Excellent
177 reviews
Price from
$179
per night

Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven

Hotel in Yaphank

Home2 Suites by Hilton Long Island Brookhaven is a 3-star property located in Yaphank. This 3-star hotel offers luggage storage space. The location is great, the hotel was clean & Olivia at the front desk was pleasant & helpful

Show more Show less
8.7
Excellent
595 reviews
Price from
$147.99
per night

Hotels with extra health and safety measures

Find hotels in Long Island with added hygiene measures plus high cleanliness ratings

Safety features
Physical distancing
Cleanliness & disinfection
Food & drink safety

Most-booked hotels in Long Island in the past month

See all

Long Island's best hotels with breakfast

See all

Budget hotels in Long Island

See all

Hotels in Long Island you can book without a credit card

See all

FAQs about hotels in Long Island

Explore guest reviews of hotels in Long Island

See all