Hotel Amara Cay Resort

Beachfront · Private Beach

80001 Overseas Highway, Islamorada, FL 33036, United States of America – Excellent location – show map

Excellent location – rated 9.1/10! (score from 662 reviews)

Real guests • Real stays • Real opinions

8.4
Very Good
663 reviews

It was great for families and the service was excellent.

Christine United States of America

close to the water, amenities, sister resorts available, close to everything

Barbara United States of America

super clean friendly staff amazing views from ocean front rooms

Kathleen United States of America

loved the location, the pool and tiki bar area, the games and amenities available.

Amanda United States of America

Great location. We really liked the outdoor games/activities along with the fire pits and pool. The rooms were newer and well maintained.

Burton United States of America

Beautiful area, cleaning was a top priority. Good food and amenities across all sister properties.

Robert United States of America

Location was perfect beautiful view of Alligator lighthouse ! family activities, tiki bar, yoga, beautiful beach and pool, fishing off dock. Quiet at night. Fun firepit to sit around.. Everything! Great breakfast too. Teen boys loved it.

Claudine United States of America

Never a dull moment! so much to do and fun to be had. Perfect place for couples or families!

Fischer United States of America

Loved the ambiance. Had a lovely lunch at tiki bar... recommend Chicken wings and Tuna poke

Fredes United States of America

Very clean and family oriented you feel safe at all times. The staff is great and the food onsite is delicious.

Lpg United States of America
8.4
Very Good
663 reviews
  • What guests loved the most:
  • “It was great for families and the service was excellent.”
    Christine Christine United States of America United States of America
  • “close to the water, amenities, sister resorts available, close to everything”
    Barbara Barbara United States of America United States of America
  • “super clean friendly staff amazing views from ocean front rooms”
    Kathleen Kathleen United States of America United States of America
  • “loved the location, the pool and tiki bar area, the games and amenities available.”
    Amanda Amanda United States of America United States of America
  • “Great location. We really liked the outdoor games/activities along with the fire pits and pool. The rooms were newer and well maintained.”
    Burton Burton United States of America United States of America
  • “Beautiful area, cleaning was a top priority. Good food and amenities across all sister properties.”
    Robert Robert United States of America United States of America
  • “Location was perfect beautiful view of Alligator lighthouse ! family activities, tiki bar, yoga, beautiful beach and pool, fishing off dock. Quiet at night. Fun firepit to sit around.. Everything!”
    Claudine Claudine United States of America United States of America
  • “Never a dull moment! so much to do and fun to be had. Perfect place for couples or families!”
    Fischer Fischer United States of America United States of America
  • “Loved the ambiance. Had a lovely lunch at tiki bar... recommend Chicken wings and Tuna poke”
    Fredes Fredes United States of America United States of America
  • “Very clean and family oriented you feel safe at all times. The staff is great and the food onsite is delicious.”
    Lpg Lpg United States of America United States of America

Categories:

  • Staff8.7
  • Facilities8.7
  • Cleanliness8.7
  • Comfort8.8
  • Value for money7.5
  • Location9.1
  • Free WiFi8.8

This beachfront hotel is located in Islamorada, Florida and features transfer services within a 3.7 mi radius. WiFi is included in the resort fee.

Guests can relax on beachside hammocks or enjoy the outdoor pool at Amara Cay Resort. An on-site fitness center is available, as well as a meeting space.

A flat-screen TV, work desk, and safety deposit box comes standard in every guestroom. Bicycle rentals and luggage storage are offered on site.

Sample a custom cocktail at the Rum Bar or experience Amara Cay Resort’s restaurant, reelburger, which offers locals and guests made-to-order burgers, fries, and frothy milkshakes.

The History of Diving Museum is 3 mi away. Guests will be 8 minutes’ drive from Anne’s beach. Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State park is 8 minutes’ drive.

Couples in particular like the location – they rated it 9.0 for a two-person trip.

Amara Cay Resort has been welcoming Booking.com guests since Oct 15, 2009

Show me more

Most popular amenities

1 swimming pool
Pet friendly
Parking
Beachfront
Family rooms
Bar

Property Highlights

Top Location: Highly rated by recent guests (9.1)

Private parking at the hotel

Saved to 3904 lists

Availability

When would you like to stay at Amara Cay Resort?

Sorry, reservations for more than 90 nights aren't possible.

Enter your dates to check availability.

Your departure date is invalid.

Check-in date
Check-out date
 
Approximate prices in USD for a 1-night stay
Loading dates...
Sleeps Room Type Price
Max adults: 4. Max children: 3
Oceanfront One-Bedroom King Suite
  • 1 king bed and
  • 1 sofa bed
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 4. Max children: 3
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 4. Max children: 3
King Room
  • 1 king bed and
  • 1 sofa bed
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 5. Max children: 2
Queen Suite
  • Bedroom 1: 2 queen beds
  • Living room: 1 sofa bed
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 5. Max children: 2
Oceanfront Suite with Two Queen Beds
  • Bedroom 1: 2 queen beds
  • Living room: 1 sofa bed
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 4. Max children: 3
King Suite
  • 1 king bed and 1 sofa bed
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 4. Max children: 3
Oceanfront King Room
  • 1 king bed and
  • 1 sofa bed
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 4. Max children: 3
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 2. Max children: 1
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 2. Max children: 1
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 4. Max children: 3
Standard King Room
  • 1 king bed and
  • 1 sofa bed
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 4. Max children: 3
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 4. Max children: 3
King Room with Partial Ocean View
  • 1 king bed and
  • 1 sofa bed
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 4. Max children: 3
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 5. Max children: 4
King Room with Sea View
  • 1 king bed and
  • 1 sofa bed
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 5. Max children: 4
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 6
Suite with Sea View
  • Bedroom 1: 2 queen beds
  • Living room: 1 sofa bed
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 2. Max children: 1
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 4. Max children: 3
King Room
  • 1 king bed and
  • 1 sofa bed
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 4. Max children: 4
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Max adults: 2. Max children: 1
Suite
  • 1 king bed
Something went wrong – please try again later.
Lock in a great price for your upcoming stay

Get instant confirmation with FREE cancellation on most rooms!

4 reasons to choose Amara Cay Resort

  • Prices you can't beat!
  • Booking is safe
  • Manage your bookings online
  • The staff speaks English

Guest reviews

8.4
Very Good · 663 reviews
Read all reviews
Categories:
  • Staff8.7
  • Facilities8.7
  • Cleanliness8.7
  • Comfort8.8
  • Value for money7.5
  • Location9.1
  • Free WiFi8.8

Select topics to read reviews:

See what guests loved the most:

  • Christine United States of America

    “It was great for families and the service was excellent.”

  • Barbara United States of America

    “close to the water, amenities, sister resorts available, close to everything”

  • Kathleen United States of America

    “super clean friendly staff amazing views from ocean front rooms”

  • Amanda United States of America

    “loved the location, the pool and tiki bar area, the games and amenities available.”

  • Burton United States of America

    “Great location. We really liked the outdoor games/activities along with the fire pits and pool. The rooms were newer and well maintained.”

  • Robert United States of America

    “Beautiful area, cleaning was a top priority. Good food and amenities across all sister properties.”

  • Claudine United States of America

    “Location was perfect beautiful view of Alligator lighthouse ! family activities, tiki bar, yoga, beautiful beach and pool, fishing off dock. Quiet at night. Fun firepit to sit around.. Everything! Great breakfast too. Teen boys loved it.”

  • Fischer United States of America

    “Never a dull moment! so much to do and fun to be had. Perfect place for couples or families!”

  • Fredes United States of America

    “Loved the ambiance. Had a lovely lunch at tiki bar... recommend Chicken wings and Tuna poke”

  • Lpg United States of America

    “Very clean and family oriented you feel safe at all times. The staff is great and the food onsite is delicious.”

Property questions and answers
Browse questions from guests for anything extra you want to know about the property

The property usually replies within a few days

  • What is your dog policy?
    Our policy includes a one-time $100 cleaning fee. The dog must weigh no more than 40lbs and be kept on a leash. We also ask that the dog be kept away from the pool area. If you have any follow up concerns or questions please give us a call! Thank you
    Answered on February 5, 2021
  • are there refrigerators in the room
    Hello! Yes, every room comes with a mini refrigerator inside.
    Answered on April 19, 2021
  • Does a standard king room have a balcony? if so what is the view?
    Yes all of our rooms have balconies
    Asked about: King Room • Answered on May 27, 2021
  • Do you offer a shuttle ride from the airport
    Our complimentary resort shuttle service is unable to travel outside of the city of Islamorada. We recommend the company Keys Shuttle for service to the airport. Thank you!
    Asked about: King Room • Answered on February 24, 2021
  • Are all your food and beverage services available on property?
    Indeed they are! Breakfast is available from 8am to 10:30am, with lunch and dinner available from 11am - 9pm on weekdays, 11am - 10pm on weekends.
    Answered on February 5, 2021

  • Still looking?

    Thanks! You'll receive an email as soon as the property answers your question.

Thanks! You'll receive an email as soon as the property answers your question.

Hotel surroundings *
Guests loved walking around the neighborhood!
Excellent location – show map
What's nearby
  • Anne s Beach
    1.7 miles
  • Upper Matecumbe Key
    1.9 miles
  • History of Diving Museum
    3 miles
  • Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park
    4.3 miles
  • Windley Key
    5 miles
Beaches in the Neighborhood
  • Sea Oats Beach
    4.9 miles
* All distances are measured in straight lines. Actual travel distances may vary.
Missing some information? Yes / No
Great! Thanks for your response.
Thanks! You'll receive an email as soon as the property answers your question.
1 Restaurant On Site

    ReelCatch

    Food: American

    Open for: Lunch, Dinner

    Menu: À la carte

Amenities of Amara Cay Resort

Most popular amenities

1 swimming pool
Pet friendly
Parking
Beachfront
Family rooms
Bar
Outdoors
  • Outdoor furniture
  • Beachfront
  • Sun deck
  • Private beach area
  • Garden
Pets
Pets are allowed. Charges may apply.