no bad points

breakfast was perfect and staff very friendly. Loved the roof space great on a sunny evening

Stayed in April 2024

Nothing!

Great location, close to everything.

Stayed in April 2024

The breakfast wasn't great, but we were very close to a ton of wonderful restaurants so it was fine.

Our room was much larger than most NYC hotel rooms; however, the one my parents stayed in at this property was quite small. We got lucky with the room assignment!

Stayed in March 2024

Always comfortable and quiet.

Stayed in February 2024

The air conditioning was a bit inconsistent

The location was superb

Stayed in April 2024

We chose this place because of the good reviews it had, specifically the cleanliness, and we were not disappointed. The place is super well located, the staff was very friendly, our room was super clean, comfortable, they even took the time to write a welcome note, the breakfast was incredible, and they allowed us to storage our suitcases after the check-out for free, to be able to continue exploring the city in comfort. It is definitely the place where we will stay every time we go to NY. Super recommended.

Stayed in April 2024

Great location , coffee machine, breakfast and roof top terrace.

Stayed in April 2024

There is nothing that we dislike about the property.

We have stayed at this hotel several times and have booked rooms for our children as gifts to stay and see a show. It is very convenient to theaters and Times Square but enough off the beaten path to feel more like you’re in a neighborhood away from the madding crowds of Times Square. Very walkable to wherever you want to go and convenient to the subway and Grand Central. Love the choice of restaurants in the neighborhood. Comfortable and welcoming. Great rooftop area. And you get breakfast!

Stayed in April 2024

Nothing to dislike.

Stayed in a 2 bedroom suite - the room was lovely, absolutely perfect for a family of four. Breakfast in adjoining restaurant was continental but lots of choice. Location was superb. Staff very friendly and helpful. Would definitely stay here again.

Stayed in April 2024

Nothing

What a wonderful experience we had at Hotel Sherman, I can truly recommend this establishment. A little gem in the middle of New York. From booking to checking in and out they exceeded our expectations. The personal touches were noticed, rarely and hugely appreciated. The rooftop was such an added bonus to our stay. Thanks for making our stay special.

Stayed in April 2024

Very clean and spacious room. Staff was attentive and accommodating.

Stayed in April 2024

It was all good

Great location and very clean

Stayed in April 2024

Pillow was a bit high for us. But it is super personal taste and we didn’t feel the need to ask for another type of them.

Everything. Super clean, staff very friendly, perfect location. The breakfast was simply delicious!

Stayed in March 2024

Inexpensive toilet paper.

Great staff. Morning breakfast. P

Stayed in April 2024

There was nothing I didn’t like or could fault.

This gorgeous little hotel was absolutely fantastic, the size of my room (I was upgraded to a king room) was absolutely perfect for me. Small kitchen area with more than what I needed, 2 big comfy chairs plus a chair and desk and a great size bathroom. I knew that New York hotel rooms were known for being quite small so this was a lovely surprise. It was also a lovely quiet oasis considering it was the perfect spot, restaurant row, theatre district, Hell’s Kitchen all right outside , not to mention Times Square only 5 minutes away.Sure I occasionally heard a door slam or people entering the lift but I would consider that very normal. Every single staff member was so nice and friendly and helpful. I wasn’t expecting too much for breakfast but honestly it had plenty of choice , enough to help you start your day and the breakfast room was lovely and light and welcoming.

Stayed in April 2024

Loved the decor and the lovely and helpful staff! Will be returning!

Stayed in April 2024

I was looking for a spacious space for myself, my daughter, and three of my budding preteen grandchildren. It worked. The balcony provided the kids a glimpse of NYC urban vistas.

Stayed in April 2024

The shower could have been hotter.

Good size room and centrally located. The breakfast had enough of a choice of items.

Stayed in March 2024

nery good

Stayed in March 2024

Had a little difficulty getting sufficient hot water during morning 'rush', although it wasn't every day and resolved itself fairly quickly. Minor niggle in an otherwise great room.

The hotel is small but our room was spacious and well appointed. The bed was huge and really comfortable, and the room was so quiet that it was unbelievable that we were in the centre of Manhattan - we had such great sleeps! The continental breakfast offering is simple but does what it needs to and the products were good. Staff were all super friendly and helpful. Hotel location is very central in Manhattan so easy to get around, and tons of great options for dinner nearby.

Stayed in March 2024

Quiet , clean and comfortable beds. Staff all very helpful and fri. Great location for a weekend in New York with easy access to all areas of the city. Lovely little boutique hotel

Stayed in March 2024

Nothing. It was all excellent.

The staff were really friendly and helpful. Our room was comfortable and large. It had a small kitchen, with a coffee machine, microwave and hot plate and cups, plates, saucers and cutlery. The hotel's location is excellent with a subway station a few blocks away with access to many lines. It is in the middle of theatre land, so perfect for Broadway shows. The hotel also provides an excellent continental breakfast, which is unusual for the US.

Stayed in March 2024

Breakfast was plentiful, and consistently tasty.

Stayed in March 2024

The noise outside the room until 2 am

Location staff and room

Stayed in March 2024