Search hotels in Shelter Island, NY
Enter your dates to see the latest prices and deals for Shelter Island hotels
Shelter Island – 3 hotels and places to stay
Filter by:
Star Rating
Review score
The Pridwin Hotel
The Pridwin is a waterfront resort located on Shelter Island with 33 well-appointed guest rooms and 16 private cottages an all-American restaurant and lively lounge with water views a full service...
Baron's Cove
Featuring an on-site restaurant and seasonal saltwater swimming pool, Baron's Cove is located in Sag Harbor, New York.
The Harbor Front Inn
Offering a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a fitness center, The Harbor Front Inn is centrally located near the shops and restaurants in Greenport. Free WiFi access is available.
Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows
Located in Greenport, 25 miles from Splish Splash, Silver Sands Motel & Beach Bungalows has accommodations with free bikes, free private parking, a garden and a private beach area.
The Menhaden Hotel
Featuring a terrace, bar and views of city, The Menhaden Hotel is located in Greenport, 26 miles from Splish Splash.
Hotel Moraine
Located in Greenport, 24 miles from Splish Splash, Hotel Moraine provides accommodations with free bikes, free private parking, a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a fitness center.
American Beech Hotel
American Beech Hotel has free bikes, garden, a restaurant and bar in Greenport. This 4-star hotel offers free WiFi. The property is allergy-free throughout and is located 26 miles from Splish Splash.
Sound View Greenport
Set on the North Fork in Greenport, 98 mi from New York City, Sound View Greenport features a seasonal outdoor pool and views of the Long Island Sound. Guests can enjoy a drink at the bar.
Sag Harbor Inn
Located in Sag Harbor, within 15 miles of Montauk Point Lighthouse and 21 miles of Second House Museum, Sag Harbor Inn has accommodations with a shared lounge as well as free private parking for...
The Shoals Suites & Slips
Located in Southold, 23 miles from Splish Splash, The Shoals Suites & Slips provides accommodations with a garden, free private parking, a terrace and a bar.
Hotels with parking in Shelter Island
- Free parkingScored out of 10, guest rating 8.8Excellent - What previous guests thought, 134 reviewsFrom $294.77 per night
- Free parkingScored out of 10, guest rating 9.3Wonderful - What previous guests thought, 316 reviewsFrom $527.85 per night
- Free parkingScored out of 10, guest rating 9.3Wonderful - What previous guests thought, 97 reviewsFrom $574.37 per night
- Free parkingScored out of 10, guest rating 9.6Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 100 reviewsFrom $479.85 per night
- Free parkingScored out of 10, guest rating 9.5Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 59 reviewsFrom $649.94 per night
- Free parkingScored out of 10, guest rating 8.2Very Good - What previous guests thought, 252 reviewsFrom $321.83 per night
- Free parkingScored out of 10, guest rating 8.3Very Good - What previous guests thought, 127 reviewsFrom $237.31 per night
- Free parkingScored out of 10, guest rating 8.6Excellent - What previous guests thought, 41 reviewsFrom $1,011.68 per night
- Free parkingScored out of 10, guest rating 8.9Excellent - What previous guests thought, 149 reviewsFrom $999.84 per night
- Free parkingScored out of 10, guest rating 8.4Very Good - What previous guests thought, 103 reviewsFrom $525.95 per night
Most booked hotels in Shelter Island and surrounding area in the past month
Popular with guests booking hotels in Shelter Island
Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.3Wonderful - What previous guests thought, 97 reviewsPopular with guests booking hotels in Greenport
Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.3Very Good - What previous guests thought, 238 reviewsPopular with guests booking hotels in Greenport
Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.9Excellent - What previous guests thought, 142 reviewsPopular with guests booking hotels in Greenport
Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.3Wonderful - What previous guests thought, 116 reviewsPopular with guests booking hotels in Greenport
Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.2Very Good - What previous guests thought, 222 reviewsPopular with guests booking hotels in Sag Harbor
Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.9Excellent - What previous guests thought, 149 reviewsPopular with guests booking hotels in Greenport
Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.5Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 59 reviewsPopular with guests booking hotels in Sag Harbor
Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.8Excellent - What previous guests thought, 91 reviewsPopular with guests booking hotels in Greenport
Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.7Excellent - What previous guests thought, 134 reviewsPopular with guests booking hotels in Greenport
Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.6Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 100 reviews
Best hotels with breakfast in Shelter Island and nearby
Seven Resort Style Inn near Beach
Hotel in Shelter Island HeightsBreakfast optionsScored out of 10, guest rating 9.8Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 64 reviewsJust 1476 feet to the beach, this bed and breakfast is located in Shelter Island Heights. A free breakfast is served each morning.
The Harbor Front Inn
Hotel in GreenportBreakfast optionsScored out of 10, guest rating 8.3Very Good - What previous guests thought, 238 reviewsOffering a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a fitness center, The Harbor Front Inn is centrally located near the shops and restaurants in Greenport. Free WiFi access is available.
American Beech Hotel
Hotel in GreenportBreakfast optionsScored out of 10, guest rating 8.9Excellent - What previous guests thought, 142 reviewsAmerican Beech Hotel has free bikes, garden, a restaurant and bar in Greenport. This 4-star hotel offers free WiFi. The property is allergy-free throughout and is located 26 miles from Splish Splash.
Sound View Greenport
Hotel in GreenportBreakfast optionsScored out of 10, guest rating 8.2Very Good - What previous guests thought, 222 reviewsSet on the North Fork in Greenport, 98 mi from New York City, Sound View Greenport features a seasonal outdoor pool and views of the Long Island Sound. Guests can enjoy a drink at the bar.
Sag Harbor Inn
Hotel in Sag HarborBreakfast optionsScored out of 10, guest rating 8.8Excellent - What previous guests thought, 91 reviewsLocated in Sag Harbor, within 15 miles of Montauk Point Lighthouse and 21 miles of Second House Museum, Sag Harbor Inn has accommodations with a shared lounge as well as free private parking for...
Harbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast
Hotel in GreenportBreakfast optionsScored out of 10, guest rating 9.8Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 20 reviewsHarbor Knoll Bed and Breakfast in Greenport provides accommodations with a seasonal outdoor swimming pool, a garden, and a bar.
Modern on 9th
Hotel in GreenportBreakfast optionsModern on 9th offers accommodations in Greenport, 25 miles from Splish Splash. The vacation home has access to a restaurant. Opening onto a patio, the vacation home consists of 3 bedrooms.
The Stirling House Waterfront Inn Greenport
Hotel in GreenportBreakfast optionsScored out of 10, guest rating 9.8Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 22 reviewsProviding a garden, The Stirling House Waterfront Inn Greenport features accommodations in Greenport. This 4-star bed and breakfast offers luggage storage space and a concierge service.
Budget hotels in Shelter Island and nearby
- Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.6Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 14 reviews
17 miles from Long Island Railroad in Greenport, Bright Apartment - half Mi to Greenport Harbor! provides accommodations with access to a spa center.
- Scored out of 10, guest rating 10.0Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 3 reviews
Featuring a spa and wellness center, Quaint DT Greenport Apt - 2 Mi to Shelter Island! features accommodations in Greenport. Guests staying at this apartment have access to a patio.
Cozy Greenport Cottage
Hotel in GreenportCheap hotelScored out of 10, guest rating 9.0Wonderful - What previous guests thought, 1 reviewCozy Greenport Cottage offers accommodations in Greenport, 26 miles from Splish Splash. Guests can benefit from a patio and an outdoor fireplace. The vacation home has an outdoor pool and a sauna.
- Scored out of 10, guest rating 10.0Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 2 reviews
Charming Greenport Gem 1, 1 Mile to Ferry! offers accommodations in Greenport, 17 miles from Long Island Railroad. The air-conditioned accommodation is 26 miles from Splish Splash.
- Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.5Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 2 reviews
North Fork Cottages & RV Resort in Greenport provides accommodations with a seasonal outdoor swimming pool and a garden.
Lavender Bay Breezes - Private Bay Beach Community offers accommodations in East Marion, 27 miles from Splish Splash and 18 miles from Long Island Railroad.
- Scored out of 10, guest rating 9.2Wonderful - What previous guests thought, 28 reviews
Offering garden views, A Walk in the Woods Bed and Breakfast in Southold features accommodations and a terrace.
Beachfront Greenport Villa
Hotel in GreenportCheap hotelBeachfront Greenport Villa offers accommodations in Greenport, 23 miles from Splish Splash and 14 miles from Long Island Railroad. This vacation home offers free private parking and free Wifi.
See reviews by guests who stayed at hotels in Shelter Island
- Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.1Very Good - What previous guests thought, 35 reviewsIt is a very charming hotel in a beautiful natural landscape with dears rabbits squirrels. The beach was cozy and the stuff was extremely nice and friendship. It was the best relaxing few days to close our New York visit. I will never forget this holiday.Guest review byTimeaHungary
- Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.1Very Good - What previous guests thought, 35 reviewsThe staff was nice and accommodating; the building was beautiful; and it was the best calm getaway I’ve had in a while. The hotel also offers kayaks and SUP for free…as well as food for the sheep that are on site.Guest review byginaUnited States
- From $439.38 per nightScored out of 10, guest rating 9.8Exceptional - What previous guests thought, 64 reviewsWe had an amazing stay at Seven. Beth and Patrick are very accommodating and friendly. Seven has everything you need for a great stay at Shelter Island. We really liked the pool, gym area and breakfast.Guest review byMarjanNetherlands
- Scored out of 10, guest rating 8.1Very Good - What previous guests thought, 35 reviewsRoom & bath were spotless. Very comfy bed. Loved the bar area, and wrap-around porch, Adirondack chairs and hammocks on the lawn, and our surprising discovery of the historic importance of the inn!Guest review byPamelaUnited States
- From $574.37 per nightScored out of 10, guest rating 9.3Wonderful - What previous guests thought, 97 reviewsVery pretty hotel and very cleanGuest review byIsabelleUnited Kingdom
Research, refine, and make plans for your whole trip
Hotels near Tweed-New Haven Airport
Hotels near Long Island MacArthur Airport
Hotels with Parking in Shelter Island
Pet-Friendly Hotels in Shelter Island
Hotels in New York
