1
The only way to leave a review is to first make a booking. That's how we know our reviews come from real guests who have stayed at the property.
2
When guests stay at the property, they check out how quiet the room is, how friendly the staff is, and more.
3
After their trip, guests tell us about their stay. We check for naughty words and verify the authenticity of all guest reviews before adding them to our site.
Ouray, Colorado
Positive section of review
My wife and I loved the entire St. Elmo experience, both the hotel and restaurant/bar. It's an historic gem of a hotel, lovingly restored and cared for. David is an exceptional host. Very, very comfortable with just enough "modern" updates so as to not distract from the fantastic step back in time. The restaurant food, and service, is also excellent. For the budget conscious like my wife and I, our stay at St. Elmo was a real splurge, but we do not regret it and will always remember it fondly.
Negative section of review
We have absolutely no dislikes. But, if you have issues physically climbing stairs you might have to pass. All rooms are on the second floor with only staircase access. FYI - We do not have any physical issues but our host David still insisted with helping us with our luggage. Very nice!
Algoma, Wisconsin
Positive section of review
Full-on breakfast, cooked every morning by the Owners, included. I'm talking eggs, sausage, bacon, waffles, bangles, cereal, fruit, coffee, juice, milk... It's friggin' nuts! And a nice pool and sauna, and a great wrap around deck with seating and games and a grill. Listen to me; stay here if your going to door county during tourist season. It's half an hour out of Sturgeon Bay, then up to wherever you're going without all the touristy hassle.
Negative section of review
What didn't we like? Having to leave.
Estes Park, Colorado
Positive section of review
The room was clean and comfortable. Loved the atypical decor (felt like a room at home vs. a motel room). High quality bedding and towels were so greatly appreciated! Easy access to downtown and to the fairgrounds where I was competing in a horseshow. AC unit a bit loud but did its job and provided good white noise as we were on the ground floor. Definitely want to mention how great the motor lodge manager, Amanda, was! So helpful, made the stay even better.
Negative section of review
Parking is a bit tricky. Could use more counter space in the bathroom.
South Padre Island, Texas
Positive section of review
Room Suite. Proximity to the beach. Pool and the amenities around the pool. Location at the south end of the Island.
Negative section of review
Room service was spotty and occasionally had to ask the cleaning staff for things they failed to provide each day.
New Holland, Pennsylvania
Positive section of review
The new bathroom with walkin shower and higher toilet seat. everything was clean and comfortable
Miami Beach, Florida
Positive section of review
The easy check in process. The location, as well as the decor.
Negative section of review
The elevators weren't in service.
Bernalillo, New Mexico
Positive section of review
Breakfast need improvement location is great .
Negative section of review
Like I said breakfast
Covington, Louisiana
Positive section of review
Beds, breakfast, staff.
Negative section of review
Broken drawer pull on bedside table.
Fort Lauderdale, Florida
Positive section of review
How big the room was
Negative section of review
The tub didn't plug
Chattanooga, Tennessee
Positive section of review
The vibe of the place was awesome. It was gigantic. Literally an ENTIRE apartment! Everything looked like NYC, modern industrial. It's amazing. Full kitchen with giant table with benches. There are dishes and pans and everything you need if you're staying there and want to eat home or have people over for dinner. There are super cool games, giant beds, just everything was amazing. Plus it was half a block from the memorial service I came for. Just perfect.
Negative section of review
I could hear drunk people singing until about 4am. It seemed to be coming through a vent in my dad's room when I tried to follow the sound. I asked the receptionist about it the next morning and he was very surprised, and said he'd never heard that complaint before so he had no idea. We were trying to figure out if it was from another building or inside our hotel. So apparently it's not a common complaint. And honestly this place was SO awesome, I can't even take away points for that. But hopefully it was just a one off.